Bottom line: For most businesses, Plausible (best UI) or Fathom (best value) are the top choices. If you need free self-hosted, go with Umami. If you need detailed data, go with Matomo.
Full Comparison
| Tool | Starting Price | Self-Hosted | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plausible | $19/mo | ✅ Free (CE) | Best overall, best UI |
| Fathom | $14/mo | ❌ | Best value, unlimited sites |
| Matomo | Free (self-hosted) | ✅ Free | Most data, custom reports |
| Umami | Free (self-hosted) | ✅ Free | Free self-hosted alternative |
| Simple Analytics | $15/mo | ❌ | Minimalist, privacy-first |
| Clicky | Free (limited) | ❌ | Real-time, heatmaps included |
When to Choose Each
- Plausible — best-looking, simplest, self-hostable
- Fathom — cheapest premium, unlimited sites
- Matomo — most powerful, self-hosted, custom reports
- Umami — free self-hosted, simple, lightweight
- Simple Analytics — if you want the simplest possible tool
- Clicky — best free real-time analytics with heatmaps
Which Alternative Should You Pick?
Best Overall: Plausible — the right balance of design, features, and price.
Best Value: Fathom — $14/mo, unlimited sites, all the core features.
Best Free: Umami — self-hosted, open source, no data limits.
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links.