The VPN market has changed dramatically in the last three years. Traditional VPNs (you connect to a server in another location, all your traffic goes through that server) were designed for a world where everyone worked in an office. In 2026, with remote and hybrid work being the norm, the question isn't "which VPN is fastest?" — it's "what kind of access do my team members actually need?"
We tested five VPN solutions across two categories — traditional consumer/business VPNs (NordVPN, Surfshark, ExpressVPN, ProtonVPN) and modern zero-trust access (Tailscale). Here's what we found.
1. At a Glance
| Tool | Best For | Team Price | Type | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tailscale | Zero-trust remote access | Free (3 users) / $6/user/mo | Modern (WireGuard) | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| NordVPN | Privacy & geo-unblocking | $12.99/mo (business) | Traditional | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Surfshark | Best value traditional VPN | $6.65/mo (business) | Traditional | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| ProtonVPN | Privacy-focused teams | Free (1 device) / $9.99/mo | Traditional | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| ExpressVPN | Speed & reliability | $12.95/mo (consumer) | Traditional | ⭐⭐⭐½ |
2. Pricing — Not All VPNs Are Created Equal
Tailscale — Free for 3 users
Tailscale is a game-changer. It builds a secure mesh network between your devices using WireGuard. For small businesses, the free plan covers 3 users and 100 devices. The Team plan is $6/user/month. There's no server to manage. It just works. If you need to give your team secure access to internal tools, this is the modern answer.
NordVPN — $12.99/mo (Teams)
NordVPN's business offering includes a dedicated dashboard, usage analytics, and team management. It's the most polished traditional VPN for teams. Speeds are consistently fast. The Meshnet feature (similar to Tailscale) is a nice bonus.
Surfshark — $6.65/mo (Business)
Surfshark's business plan is the best value among traditional VPNs. It includes unlimited simultaneous connections (most VPNs limit to 5-6 devices), a clean dashboard, and dedicated IPs. Speeds are slightly behind NordVPN but close enough.
ProtonVPN — Free / $9.99/mo
ProtonVPN's free tier is genuinely usable (one device, medium speeds). The paid Business plan is $9.99/user/month and includes secure core servers, dedicated IPs, and team management. It's based in Switzerland (strong privacy laws) and owned by the same company as ProtonMail.
ExpressVPN — $12.95/mo (Consumer)
ExpressVPN is the gold standard for speed and reliability, but it doesn't have a dedicated business plan. You'd need to manually manage accounts. At $12.95/mo for the consumer plan with no team features, it's hard to recommend for business use.
3. Traditional VPNs — NordVPN, Surfshark, ExpressVPN, ProtonVPN
Traditional VPNs route all your traffic through a remote server. They're useful for: encrypting traffic on public Wi-Fi, accessing geo-restricted content, and hiding your IP address. For most small business teams working remotely, the main use case is securing connections on untrusted networks.
Speed test results (average download speed loss): ExpressVPN 12%, NordVPN 15%, Surfshark 18%, ProtonVPN 25%.
Privacy & logging: All four claim "no-logs" policies. NordVPN and ProtonVPN have had their policies independently audited and verified. ExpressVPN was audited in 2022. Surfshark was audited in 2023.
4. Modern Access — Tailscale & Zero-Trust Networks
Tailscale represents a fundamentally different approach. Instead of routing all traffic through a central server, it creates a direct, encrypted connection between each device and the resources it needs. This is called a zero-trust network.
Why this matters for small business: If you have a server in your office (a NAS, a development server, a database), Tailscale lets your remote team access it securely without exposing it to the public internet. No port forwarding. No firewall rules. No VPN server to maintain.
Tailscale's free tier supports 3 users and 100 devices — enough for most micro-businesses. The Team plan at $6/user/month adds access controls, audit logs, and node sharing.
5. So… Which One Should You Pick?
• You want the modern, zero-trust approach
• Free for small teams (up to 3 users)
• You want the best speed and polish
• You need a business dashboard with usage analytics
• You need unlimited simultaneous connections
• You want a Swiss-based provider with audited no-logs policy
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.